CLIENT FOCUSED! RESULTS DRIVEN! SERVICE YOU CAN COUNT ON!
Contact Marian Casteel
Contacting Marian Casteel
  • All fields are required.
Schedule A Showing
Schedule a Showing.
  • All fields are required.
Check this box to Register with us:
Submit an Offer Now!
Submit an Offer Now!
All fields are required.
Print Flyer
5169 Sandy Shore Avenue, SARASOTA, FL 34242
  1. Image 1 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  2. Image 2 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  3. Image 3 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  4. Image 4 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  5. Image 5 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  6. Image 6 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  7. Image 7 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  8. Image 8 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  9. Image 9 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  10. Image 10 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  11. Image 11 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  12. Image 12 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  13. Image 13 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  14. Image 14 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  15. Image 15 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  16. Image 16 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  17. Image 17 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  18. Image 18 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  19. Image 19 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  20. Image 20 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  21. Image 21 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  22. Image 22 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  23. Image 23 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  24. Image 24 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  25. Image 25 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  26. Image 26 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  27. Image 27 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  28. Image 28 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  29. Image 29 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  30. Image 30 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  31. Image 31 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  32. Image 32 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  33. Image 33 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  34. Image 34 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  35. Image 35 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  36. Image 36 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  37. Image 37 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  38. Image 38 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  39. Image 39 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  40. Image 40 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  41. Image 41 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  42. Image 42 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  43. Image 43 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  44. Image 44 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  45. Image 45 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  46. Image 46 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  47. Image 47 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  48. Image 48 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
Property Photos
5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
Image Gallery
Would you like to sell your home before you purchase this one?
Priced at Only: $3,290,000
For more Information Call:
Address: 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Property Location and Similar Properties
All
Similar
  1. Image 1 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  2. Image 2 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  3. Image 3 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  4. Image 4 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  5. Image 5 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  6. Image 6 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  7. Image 7 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  8. Image 8 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  9. Image 9 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  10. Image 10 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  11. Image 11 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  12. Image 12 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  13. Image 13 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  14. Image 14 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  15. Image 15 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  16. Image 16 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  17. Image 17 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  18. Image 18 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  19. Image 19 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  20. Image 20 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  21. Image 21 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  22. Image 22 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  23. Image 23 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  24. Image 24 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  25. Image 25 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  26. Image 26 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  27. Image 27 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  28. Image 28 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  29. Image 29 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  30. Image 30 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  31. Image 31 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  32. Image 32 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  33. Image 33 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  34. Image 34 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  35. Image 35 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  36. Image 36 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  37. Image 37 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  38. Image 38 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  39. Image 39 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  40. Image 40 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  41. Image 41 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  42. Image 42 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  43. Image 43 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  44. Image 44 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  45. Image 45 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  46. Image 46 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  47. Image 47 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  48. Image 48 of 48 For 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
Request More Information
  • All fields are required.
Virtual Tour
Reduced
More Like This
  • MLS#: A4641428 ( Residential )
  • Street Address: 5169 Sandy Shore Avenue
  • Viewed: 61
  • Price: $3,290,000
  • Price sqft: $703
  • Waterfront: Yes
  • Wateraccess: Yes
  • Waterfront Type: Canal - Saltwater
  • Year Built: 2015
  • Bldg sqft: 4678
  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Total Baths: 4
  • Full Baths: 3
  • 1/2 Baths: 1
  • Garage / Parking Spaces: 3
  • Days On Market: 50
  • Additional Information
  • Geolocation: 27.2772 / -82.5559
  • County: SARASOTA
  • City: SARASOTA
  • Zipcode: 34242
  • Subdivision: Sara Sands
  • Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
  • Middle School: Brookside Middle
  • High School: Sarasota High
  • Provided by: WATERSIDE REALTY LLC
  • Contact: Andrew Barnhardt
  • 941-346-7454
  • mfrmls
  • DMCA Notice
  • Description
    One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Now offered at $3,290,000, this custom designed Siesta Key waterfront home presents a rare opportunity to live where every day feels like a vacation at a newly improved price. Built in 2015 by Lee Wetherington and maintained with exceptional care, the home blends timeless Key West architecture with modern comforts and an unbeatable island location, just moments from Siesta Key Beach and Village. Tucked at the end of a peaceful cul de sac, the setting offers a sense of calm from the moment you arrive. Inside, rich wood floors, soaring 12 foot cathedral ceilings, and natural light create a space that feels both elegant and relaxed. An open floor plan connects the living room, dining area, and chefs kitchen designed for effortless living and entertaining. The kitchen features custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and a large walk in pantry. Whether youre cooking for friends or enjoying coffee in the morning sun, the space encourages ease and connection. The spa like primary suite is located on the main level for privacy and convenience, while two additional ensuite guest rooms provide comfort for visiting family and friends. Step outside and experience what makes this home truly special. A heated saltwater pool and spa, full outdoor kitchen, and covered patio overlook a wide canal with a private dock, boat lift, new seawall, and fish cleaning station. This is a true boaters paradise perfect for paddleboarding before breakfast or sunset cruises after dinner. The fully fenced backyard is ideal for pets, play, or simply relaxing in the shade of the palms. Additional highlights include hurricane rated impact windows, elevated construction (main living at 10.5 feet above sea level), new HVAC, fresh interior paint, and a spacious 3 car garage with a split configuration ideal for hobbies or specialty vehicles. With no HOA and a warm neighborhood feel, the property offers not only beauty and functionality but freedom and peace of mind. With a recent $90,000 price improvement, the home now offers exceptional value for discerning buyers and for boating enthusiasts, that could mean instant boat money for upgrades, gear, or your next sunset cruiser. Located just a short walk from Siesta Key Beach named the #1 beach in the U.S. and #3 in the world in 2025 the home offers the best of the island lifestyle. Stroll to the beach for sunset, walk to dinner in the Village, or meet friends for a casual happy hour. Whether youre seeking a full time residence or a serene coastal retreat, this is the one that will make you feel at home the moment you step inside. Opportunities like this are rare. Come see what makes this home unforgettable and why it might just be the one youve been waiting for.
Payment Calculator
  •   Principal & Interest -
  •   Property Tax $
  •   Home Insurance $
  •   HOA Fees $
  •   Mortgage Insurance-
  •   Monthly -
For a Fast & FREE Mortgage Pre-ApprovalApply Now
Features
Building and Construction
  • Covered Spaces: 0.00
  • Exterior Features: French Doors, Irrigation System, Outdoor Kitchen, Outdoor Shower, Rain Gutters, Sliding Doors
  • Fencing: Fenced
  • Flooring: Hardwood, Tile
  • Living Area: 2885.00
  • Roof: Metal
Land Information
  • Lot Features: Cul-De-Sac, FloodZone, Landscaped, Paved
School Information
  • High School: Sarasota High
  • Middle School: Brookside Middle
  • School Elementary: Phillippi Shores Elementary
Garage and Parking
  • Garage Spaces: 3.00
  • Open Parking Spaces: 0.00
  • Parking Features: Circular Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Split Garage, Workshop in Garage
Eco-Communities
  • Pool Features: Heated, In Ground, Lighting, Salt Water, Self Cleaning, Tile
  • Water Source: Public
Utilities
  • Carport Spaces: 0.00
  • Cooling: Central Air, Humidity Control, Zoned
  • Heating: Electric, Propane
  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Utilities: Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Fiber Optics, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
Finance and Tax Information
  • Home Owners Association Fee: 0.00
  • Insurance Expense: 0.00
  • Net Operating Income: 0.00
  • Other Expense: 0.00
  • Tax Year: 2024
Other Features
  • Appliances: Built-In Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer, Water Filtration System, Water Softener, Wine Refrigerator
  • Country: US
  • Furnished: Unfurnished
  • Interior Features: Built-in Features, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fans(s), Crown Molding, High Ceilings, Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Smart Home, Solid Wood Cabinets, Stone Counters, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar
  • Legal Description: LOT 54 SARA SANDS UNIT 4
  • Levels: Two
  • Area Major: 34242 - Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
  • Occupant Type: Vacant
  • Parcel Number: 0081140027
  • Style: Coastal, Florida, Key West
  • View: Pool, Water
  • Views: 61
  • Zoning Code: RSF2
Similar Properties

Details for 4940 Peaceable Way, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,200,000.00 ($558.27 / sqft )

4940 Peaceable Way Virtual Tour More Like This

Experience the epitome of Siesta Key living in this exquisitely crafted residence near Siesta Village and renowned pristine beaches, with every conceivable amenity nearby. On a generous one third acre

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 5
  3. Approx. 5732 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4642257
  2. Provided by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY
  3. Contact Judie Berger
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
77 Pictures and Information
Details for 296 Treasure Boat Way, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,450,000.00 ($723.42 / sqft )

296 Treasure Boat Way More Like This

You have found it! Welcome to this impressive custom built West Indies inspired home that has it all. Nestled in an ideal location and a quick walk to the vibrant Siesta Village and world famous cryst

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 4
  3. Approx. 4769 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4646505
  2. Provided by STARLINK REALTY INC
  3. Contact Dave Herring
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
49 Pictures and Information
Details for 497 Island Circle, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,000,000.00 ($576.04 / sqft )

497 Island Circle Virtual Tour More Like This

Discover your coastal retreat in the heart of Siesta Key, where lush gardens create a relaxing oasis near the Gulf. This stunning four bedroom, three and a half bath coastal contemporary home offers a

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 4
  3. Approx. 5208 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4647686
  2. Provided by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY
  3. Contact Judie Berger
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
85 Pictures and Information
Details for 6934 Belgrave Drive, SIESTA KEY, FL 34242
$3,475,000.00 ($553.26 / sqft )

6934 Belgrave Drive Virtual Tour Reduced More Like This

No Hurricane Damages on this one. Your dream home on Siesta Key just became more attractive! This home has proven its strength and durability during our last hurricane season. There was absolutely

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 7
  3. Approx. 6281 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4597222
  2. Provided by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
  3. Contact Kris Niehaus
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
53 Pictures and Information
Details for 0 Ocean Boulevard, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,900,000.00 ($486.35 / sqft )

0 Ocean Boulevard Virtual Tour New Construction More Like This

Pre Construction. To be built. Saltwater canal enjoy the best of Siesta Key living in this upcoming new build just a few minutes walk from world renowned beaches and steps away from Siesta Key vill

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 5
  2. Baths: 6
  3. Approx. 8019 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4613022
  2. Provided by BETTER HOMES & GARDENS REAL ES
  3. Contact Lisa Shepard
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
79 Pictures and Information
Details for 4903 Commonwealth Drive, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,250,000.00 ($585.48 / sqft )

4903 Commonwealth Drive New Construction More Like This

Pre Construction. To be built. An opportunity to own a Custom Home on Siesta Key built by Nutter Custom Construction. Limited time during the pre construction phase to influence selections. This beaut

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 4
  3. Approx. 5551 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4643229
  2. Provided by NCC PROPERTIES LLC
  3. Contact Terence Nutter
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
6 Pictures and Information
Details for 8855 Midnight Pass Road, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$2,995,000.00 ($323.54 / sqft )

8855 Midnight Pass Road Virtual Tour More Like This

Huge price improvement! Offering unparalleled privacy and tranquility, this extraordinary Siesta Key estate is a testament to both luxury and resilience. Spanning double lots over half an acre, gated

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 5
  3. Approx. 9257 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4632077
  2. Provided by EXP REALTY LLC
  3. Contact Mark Coppens
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
98 Pictures and Information
Details for 3920 Roberts Point Road, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,495,000.00 ($502.16 / sqft )

3920 Roberts Point Road More Like This

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Certain cryptocurrencies accepted. An exquisite waterfront retreat in siesta key, sarasota, fl a sanctuary of coastal luxury. Enter the fully remodeled

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 5
  3. Approx. 6960 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4625300
  2. Provided by MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY
  3. Contact Melissa Gissinger
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
42 Pictures and Information
Details for 8030 Midnight Pass Road, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,295,000.00 ($674.79 / sqft )

8030 Midnight Pass Road New Construction More Like This

Major price reduction for immediate sale. Construction just completed on this new residence on the south end of Siesta Key. Located on Heron Lagoon offering breathtaking sunset views from various vant

  1. Request Information
  1. Bedrooms: 4
  2. Baths: 6
  3. Approx. 4883 sqft
  1. MLSID: A4625440
  2. Provided by MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY
  3. Contact Kim Ogilvie
  4. mfrmls
  5. DMCA Notice
99 Pictures and Information
Nearby Subdivisions
0073 Siesta Rev Plat Of   Bay Island   Bay Island Park   Bay Island Shores   Bayou Louise 28   Beach Club At Siesta Key   Boyds   Cedars Of Siesta Key The   Cocoanut Bayou   Fidder Bayou   Harbor Towers Y R   Harmony   Harmony Sub   Heron Lagoon Lodges   Hidden Harbor   Horizons West   La Siesta   Lake Rittwood   Lot 5 Sara Sands   Mangroves Sub The   Midnight Harbor Sub   Midnight Pass Road   Mira Mar Beach   Mira Mar Sub   No Subdivision Sarasota County   Ocean Beach Rep   Ocean Beach Sub   Ocean View   Paradise Island   Point Crisp Add   Point O Rocks Terrace Add   Point Of Rocks   Polynesian Gardens   Riegels Landing   Roberts Point   Roberts Point 2   Royal Palm Harbor   Sanderling Club   Sanderling Club Siesta Key   Sanderling Club Siesta Propert   Sanderling Clubsiesta Properti   Sandy Hook   Sara Sands   Sarasota Beach   Secluded Harbour 02   Siesta Beach   Siesta Cove Sub   Siesta Isles   Siesta Key   Siesta Manor Sec 3   Siesta Pines   Siesta Rev Of   Siesta Rev Plat Of   Siesta Rev Resub   Siestas Bayside   Siestas Bayside Bayside Club 0   Siestas Bayside Waterside East   Siestas Bayside Waterside Sout   Siestas Bayside Waterside West   Siestas Bayside Waterside Wood   Siestas Bayside Watersidewood   Stickney Point Sub   Tortoise Estates   Twin Oak Pond   Twitchell Ralph S Siesta Key P   Village Sands 1   Vista Hermosa   White Beach Fruit Co Prop  
Skip to Main Content
Headshot for Associate Marian Casteel
  1. Marian Casteel, BrkrAssc,REALTOR ®
  2. Tropic Shores Realty
  3. CLIENT FOCUSED! RESULTS DRIVEN! SERVICE YOU CAN COUNT ON!
  4. Mobile: 352.601.6367
  5. Mobile: 352.601.6367
  6. 352.601.6367
  7. mariancasteel@yahoo.com